I totally agree with your post and understand your point, although...
I would never want a client to see me who, for example, really really dislikes tattoos but is trying to "broaden his horizons" and I am left feeling like he is not attracted to me during our session because I can sense his body language and verbal cues.
I want my clients to have some form of sexual attraction to me. Knowing my client finds me irresistible is actually a turn on and the confidence it gives me during a session helps my passion.
If they truly dislike sexworkers my age, my weight, or with attributes I have, I would rather they not see me.
It could lead to a bad experience for them and I or a negative review that is undeserved only because they had seen me knowing I am not their type.
And I have seen this review issue happen many times, not personally thank heavens.
I am going the reverse direction. More and more picky. Experimentation is a good phase, but then you know what you like. Of course, the difference in price from when I started to now is a factor mentally - as is the general shift in personality of this generation.
That being said, the principle is sound. But really how close do you get even when being "picky" to your platonic ideal? And in defense to the idea - unexpected gems are a blast!