Leafs 2026-2027 Season

I don't think people care how many coaches they're paying, what's embarrassing is hiring coaches that aren't fit for for the job.
Babcock, Keefe, Berube....all different with same results... Hiller is the only guy that looks like a stiff.
They don't have D, they don't have depth, they don't have chemistry, they're trying to coach around what they got.
They don't even have a legit 2C.
 
I believe it was Elliotte Friedman who recently said " you don't choose rebuild, rebuild finds you" and that's exactly the situation the Leafs are in now. This team is so broken that it won't be long before Matthews wants out, and I don't think anyone who's been watching every game can blame him. He's been playing with his heart out and his complete effort is there every night. Rebuild is already knocking.

I can imagine how frustrating it must be for Matthews to see a teammate plays with half ass effort most games and I'm not talking about Bobrovsky. Bob has been really bad but that is because he's reached the end of his playing career, not unlike Nylander who's still in his prime. Both Matthews and Hiller have talked about "cheating the game" after a loss and you'd be a child to not know who they're talking about.

If the Leafs are serious about keeping Matthews, they should do everything within their power to force a Nylander trade. Not only that'll bring defence help in return, I'd also venture to guess that it'll please Matthews. Trading Nylander is an eventual certainty whether they're retooling or rebuilding as barring miracles this team will continue to suck and Matthews will leave anyway. Trading Nylander for defence help will not solve ALL their problems, but at least it'd offer some hope for a quicker turnaround.
 
If the Leafs are serious about keeping Matthews, they should do everything within their power to force a Nylander trade. Not only that'll bring defence help in return, I'd also venture to guess that it'll please Matthews. Trading Nylander is an eventual certainty whether they're retooling or rebuilding as barring miracles this team will continue to suck and Matthews will leave anyway. Trading Nylander for defence help will not solve ALL their problems, but at least it'd offer some hope for a quicker turnaround.
I explain to you the Matthews/Nylander scenario. They don't like each other by the sounds of it. Nylander has made it clear he'll only waive his no trade if the team is in a rebuild. That's means Matthews has to be traded first. If they ask him to waive it before trading Matthews then he knows they are doing it to please Matthews and not him. So he ain't going anywhere.
 
I explain to you the Matthews/Nylander scenario. They don't like each other by the sounds of it. Nylander has made it clear he'll only waive his no trade if the team is in a rebuild. That's means Matthews has to be traded first. If they ask him to waive it before trading Matthews then he knows they are doing it to please Matthews and not him. So he ain't going anywhere.
It's so Nylander, he's willing to stay where he's not wanted and where he's in conflict with teammates because he wants everything on his own terms.
If you're willing to leave because of a rebuild why wouldn't you be willing to leave because you're not wanted even by your own teammates. He wants a payout.
The cancer grows, and fuck the Leafs for rewarding and allowing this cancer to grow.
 
It's so Nylander, he's willing to stay where he's not wanted and where he's in conflict with teammates because he wants everything on his own terms.
If you're willing to leave because of a rebuild why wouldn't you be willing to leave because you're not wanted even by your own teammates. He wants a payout.
The cancer grows, and fuck the Leafs for rewarding and allowing this cancer to grow.
That's pretty much every TML player in history with a NMC. JFJ had the same issue with players when he was GM.
 
That's pretty much every TML player in history with a NMC. JFJ had the same issue with players when he was GM.
My memory fails me.
The thing with Nylander is that he would leave if it was rebuild, but he'll dig his heels in to stay on a team that's going nowhere. That's how much he gives a shit about winning.
I understand a guy doesn't want to be moved around at the end of his career or flipped at the trade line.
But Nylander could be an impact player on the right team rather than wallow in mediocrity for the rest of his career playing shinny hockey.
 
My memory fails me.
The thing with Nylander is that he would leave if it was rebuild, but he'll dig his heels in to stay on a team that's going nowhere. That's how much he gives a shit about winning.
I understand a guy doesn't want to be moved around at the end of his career or flipped at the trade line.
But Nylander could be an impact player on the right team rather than wallow in mediocrity for the rest of his career playing shinny hockey.
Sundin McCabe Tucker and Kabrle. They tried to trade Domi but he went crying to Tannebaum. I don't think Nylander has very high trade value. Not as much as Leafs fans believe and the only team in need of a coring winger at the moment is Ottawa.
 
Last edited:
Sundin McCabe Tucker and Kabrle. They tried to trade Domi but he went crying to Tannebaum. I don't think Nylander has very high trade value. Not as much as Leafs fans believe and the only team in need of a coring winger at the moment is Ottawa.
For some reason I just remember Sundin. I thought that was on Burke's time, maybe I'm confused.
I agree with you about Nylander's value although I think they can fetch something half decent, but to your point, not what Leaf fans think.
I remember shortly after he was drafted, some hockey insiders were saying that Nylander was actually ranked in the top three or four prospects in the draft,
but he slid to 8th because of the Nylander legacy, looks like they were right.
No different now in terms of trade value.
 
For some reason I just remember Sundin. I thought that was on Burke's time, maybe I'm confused.
I agree with you about Nylander's value although I think they can fetch something half decent, but to your point, not what Leaf fans think.
I remember shortly after he was drafted, some hockey insiders were saying that Nylander was actually ranked in the top three or four prospects in the draft,
but he slid to 8th because of the Nylander legacy, looks like they were right.
No different now in terms of trade value.
Sundin was on JFJ's time. Same with Tucker and McCabe then both were bought out. Kable vetoed a trade to Philly that would had Jeff Carter and a 1st round draft pick coming to Toronto. Burke later convinced him to accept a trade to Montreal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mellowjello
Nylander has made it clear he'll only waive his no trade if the team is in a rebuild.
I have not read or heard anything to that effect. Care to share where you got that information ? There's a speculation that the team has recently asked him if he would waive his no trade but Nylander hasn't addressed that as you've alluded to.

I did watch an interview in which Nylander said something to the effect that he loved playing in Toronto and didn't want to leave. That was some time ago. He has a negotiated right so no trade can happen without his consent, but things can turn ugly if this team continues to suck. He can get benched or scratched. Fan can turn on him and make him a scapegoat for the team's failure. He witnessed first hand how ugly it got for Marner who had turned down a trade to Carolina for Rantanen.

Nylander's situation is a bit different from both Sundin and Marner. The latters were in the final year of their contracts but Nylander still has about 5 years left. That's a long time to get stuck in if he feels he's not wanted by the majority of fans. Can he see any real chance for this team to be a cup contender within the next 3-5 years if he sticks around , or all he cares is just collecting his paychecks and has no aspirations of winning ?

My point really is with the situation both he and the team are in, itd be for mutual benefit if they part way. It may not happen anytime soon but if it does, I don't think we'll hear anything publicly beforehand.
 
Make it 9 in a row losses, you can go place your bets on this one. Leaf fans left counting games when Hiller gets fired.
 
I have not read or heard anything to that effect. Care to share where you got that information ? There's a speculation that the team has recently asked him if he would waive his no trade but Nylander hasn't addressed that as you've alluded to.

I did watch an interview in which Nylander said something to the effect that he loved playing in Toronto and didn't want to leave. That was some time ago. He has a negotiated right so no trade can happen without his consent, but things can turn ugly if this team continues to suck. He can get benched or scratched. Fan can turn on him and make him a scapegoat for the team's failure. He witnessed first hand how ugly it got for Marner who had turned down a trade to Carolina for Rantanen.

Nylander's situation is a bit different from both Sundin and Marner. The latters were in the final year of their contracts but Nylander still has about 5 years left. That's a long time to get stuck in if he feels he's not wanted by the majority of fans. Can he see any real chance for this team to be a cup contender within the next 3-5 years if he sticks around , or all he cares is just collecting his paychecks and has no aspirations of winning ?

My point really is with the situation both he and the team are in, itd be for mutual benefit if they part way. It may not happen anytime soon but if it does, I don't think we'll hear anything publicly beforehand.
It has been mentioned a few times on the The Fan 590 that he'll only waive if the team goes into a rebuild. Can't judge a player by body language but it just seems like he only cares about stats and money ergo why negotiating both of his contracts were always a stalemate with him. Both times he resigned shortly after David Pasternak did and got paid a little more than him even though it's safe to say Pasta is a much better and more productive player than William. And much like Mitch his dad is an issue for teams when negotiating with him.
 
Let's go back to last summer shall we? What if this hackwork patch job being done to the roster doesn't work? This was always the risk.
I think fans complain that the plan should've been to rebuild. Well hard to do so when you don't own your own first round picks in the next two drafts and also carry 5 veterans on the roster with full NMCs.
 
I think fans complain that the plan should've been to rebuild. Well hard to do so when you don't own your own first round picks in the next two drafts and also carry 5 veterans on the roster with full NMCs.

So analytics has told them to go all in on a short stack and a weak hand expecting a huge return. This is the direction Pelley has lead them to.
 
I've asked before with no answer so I'll ask again. What should've Pelley done.
[/QUOTE

Furthermore.....this the logic that has gotten them to where they are today.

To answer your question. Have you ever seen the movie Margin Call from 2011? The firm realizes nearly everything they own is a toxic asset. To stay afloat they sell off everything to willing buyers and layoff a lot of employees.

The yard sale should have started a long time ago. I don't care about NMC. Every trade doesn't need to be won. Just get rid of the toxicity
 
Did anyone watch the 2nd intermission? Elliot Friedman explained how the Leafs can leverage a trade with Boston or Philly if their pick falls within the top 10. If the Leafs' pick falls within the top 10, they can decide who is going to get it, Boston or Philly, and the Leafs can use this as leverage for a trade. I'd suspect it would be like a 4th-round pick. But it's all pending Bettman's approval.
 
Did anyone watch the 2nd intermission? Elliot Friedman explained how the Leafs can leverage a trade with Boston or Philly if their pick falls within the top 10. If the Leafs' pick falls within the top 10, they can decide who is going to get it, Boston or Philly, and the Leafs can use this as leverage for a trade. I'd suspect it would be like a 4th-round pick. But it's all pending Bettman's approval.
So what? It's a 4th-round pick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roddermac