$12 bottle of wine vs. $55 bottle of wine

Corey

Member
Dec 24, 2001
914
0
16
Can you tell the difference?

I've had both and I can't tell the difference.

Needless to say, I am not a wine expert and my judgement is based on taste and whether it goes down easy or not.
 

Brill

Well-known member
Jun 29, 2008
8,677
1,191
113
Toronto
Me too, one reason I don't want to be a wine expert. I already know what I like, I don't need to know the reason.
 

Luton

Active member
Jun 7, 2012
1,110
20
38
As someone who enjoys my wine you can find decent wines at $12 but I have never encountered a great wine at that price. You can find great wines around the $50 mark but you can also find very disappointing wines. Research is the key in deciding what wine to purchase, whether it is a $12 or $55 bottle. Check reviews or recommendations from people you trust. But the bottom line is drink wine that you enjoy. We all have different tastes.
 

doggystyle99

Well-known member
May 23, 2010
7,899
1,211
113
Can you tell the difference?

I've had both and I can't tell the difference.

Needless to say, I am not a wine expert and my judgement is based on taste and whether it goes down easy or not.
I drink a lot of wine (mostly red) and over the years have acquired a palate for it. There are some really good wines between $12-15 and then there are some very average wines. But there are so many different flavours when drinking wines that it becomes a personal preference, some people like the more fruity wines and others like the more oak flavours. I personally like all flavours it just depends on what I am eating it with, or if it's summer or winter.
Even at the $55 per bottle wine there are some really good ones and some really average ones.
One of my favourite red wines is a Rioja Marques De Riscal from Spain and is $25/bottle, it is a great wine. This wine is better than a lot of $50-60 wines. Suggestion is to find out what your personal preference is and try to find the wines you prefer.
 

VERYBADBOY

Active member
Dec 22, 2003
5,364
36
38
Back in the 6ix
Of course... $43, the bottle deposit is the same

VBB
 

Mr Bret

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2012
5,493
959
113
Agree with the previous comments.
Better chance of finding a good or great bottle at the higher price, etc.

But, I find it hard to believe that there could be so drastic a difference that the $43 difference would be justified.

And no, I'm not a connoisseur. When I like something, I like it. It's as simple as that.
 

Occasionally

Active member
May 22, 2011
2,926
8
38
Like everything in life:

Cheapest products on the market: Probably not very good, but depending what it is it still might get the job done. And it's crap you don't care about impressing people anyway...... toothpicks, bottle opener, rolls of Christmas gift wrap etc...

Affordable mainstream products: To me, the best overall tier and best bang for the buck. But it takes reading reviews and trial and errors. Typically tons of products, some crap, some ok, and some excellent. If you find stuff you like here that is quality, stick with it.

High end tier: Almost always there's a some kind of image/status part of it. Designer brands, fancy packaging, if it's an electrical gadget there's sure some extra bells and whistles. Quality usually skews to higher quality, but sometimes not. For example, Calvin Klein clothes skew to higher prices, but I think the quality is awful. I've bought my share of CK clothes for the office and find it worse than wearing a $30 Arrow shirt. You'd think a shirt costing triple more would be better. Nope. If you find a quality product and can afford it, stick with it. If it sucks, then you just got ripped off by all the marketing people at that company who sold you a "premium product". On the plus side, the product probably looks nice and people may stare at it with amazement, so at least you get some brownie points for image.

As for wine, I'm not to one to ask, but I remember reading about a taste test with wine experts and they didn't fare well at all. So it shows even wine professionals can't tell a good wine to a bad one. I've read that Costco and Trader Joe wines are even pretty good and they go for cheap. That means quality wines can be sold for cheap and still be profitable.
 

italianguy74

New member
Apr 3, 2011
1,798
1
0
GTA
As long as it doesn't taste like vinegar or too bitter I couldn't care less how inexpensive the bottle is. lol
 

Mr610

Active member
Jul 20, 2011
162
68
28
I love a lot of full body Italian wines but I have to say best value wine in the Market place is an Argentina Wine Fuzion
It recently went up to $8.25 a bottle from $7.95 For those of you that have not tried it go out and buy yourself a case and come back and say Thank you
 

sashimi

Member
Feb 13, 2014
540
0
16
Another concept is the QPR rating - Quality Price Ratio - which is also subjective.

A $12 wine taste alone maybe rated 88 v 92 for a $55 wine. But on QPR basis the 88 become
91 whereas the 92 becomes 90 which infers the $12 is an absolute bargain. However taste wise
you may much prefer the $55.
 

Corey

Member
Dec 24, 2001
914
0
16
Thanks everyone for your comments.

I had wine from a $55 bottle the other day, saw it had good reviews online and couldn't tell the difference from the $12-$15 bottles I normally drink.
 

yogi1

Active member
Oct 31, 2014
526
163
43
Thanks everyone for your comments.

I had wine from a $55 bottle the other day, saw it had good reviews online and couldn't tell the difference from the $12-$15 bottles I normally drink.
A decanter is your best friend! Changes a mediocre wine to a great wine!
 

Corey

Member
Dec 24, 2001
914
0
16
A decanter is your best friend! Changes a mediocre wine to a great wine!
We even gave it time to air out and when I tried it, I thought, good thing the wine was a gift because I honestly couldn't tell the difference.

Granted, my standards are low: Did it go down easy? Did I choke?
 
May 8, 2010
1,015
1
0
I can't tell the difference between an expensive vs inexpensive bottle of wine...So for me an expensive wine is just a waste.
 

drstrangelove

Well-known member
Mar 26, 2004
1,242
335
83
One problem is the higher prices you pay for celebrity wine, the ones with someone's famous name on the label, e.g. Mike Weir, Lynn Crawford, etc. Don't think the taste of the wine justifies the higher price you pay for the name.
 

lomotil

Well-known member
Mar 14, 2004
6,812
1,652
113
Oblivion
I drink a lot of wine (mostly red) and over the years have acquired a palate for it. There are some really good wines between $12-15 and then there are some very average wines. But there are so many different flavours when drinking wines that it becomes a personal preference, some people like the more fruity wines and others like the more oak flavours. I personally like all flavours it just depends on what I am eating it with, or if it's summer or winter.
Even at the $55 per bottle wine there are some really good ones and some really average ones.
One of my favourite red wines is a Rioja Marques De Riscal from Spain and is $25/bottle, it is a great wine. This wine is better than a lot of $50-60 wines. Suggestion is to find out what your personal preference is and try to find the wines you prefer.
That wine from Spain is a gem and economically priced due to surplus in Spain and a weak Euro. The LCBO is able to purchase this very good wine for a relatively low price and not market it up. Wine prices are based on many things, quite often it is supply and demand as actual taste is extremely subjective.
 

harryass

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2010
3,253
960
113
get the cheap stuff, no diff to most folks except the wanna be wine snobs label readers.
 

lakebear

Banned
Sep 27, 2007
1,352
2
38
North GTA
I buy a red wine from Chilie or an Italian red wine.

Both bottles are one litre and a half for about $15.00.
They do the job, have a glass with your pasta or meat.
Good deal all over, cheers!
 
Toronto Escorts