Rockslinger said:
How long will an image on a memory card survive? ... (I had really bad experience with VHS tapes where images were totally grainy in 10-15 years.)
tboy said:
There is some speculation that CDs will only last 50 yrs +/-. As for storing the files "digitally" on a card, as long as the card is not exposed to magnetic fields, or extreme heat etc it should be indefinite. But you may find that the technology changes so you won't be able to read the card. This will probably happen long before the file is corrupted on the card. I for one had a bunch of stuff stored and backedup via an archive application and when I went to XP the software wouldn't load to retrieve the files so I was screwed.
If one has demand to transfer files often you could pick up a $5.00 memory USB drive. It's a lot easier and you can move all types of files easily.....
Your advice tboy is very much lines up with my experience burning critical company data to CDs and DVDs. I abandoned tape drives back in 1995 for the same reasons tboy mentioned and switched to CD/DVD for backup storage.
CD/DVD is totally different technology from old VHS/BETA and backup tape drives. For a CD/DVD, laser beam glides over top of the disc and reads the data so there is no physical contact (friction) to damage the Disk. With the old tape technology, the data was stored using magnetic particles and there was friction (as well as surrounding magnetic forces) that used to misalign some magnetic particles each time you used the tape. This is why rockslinger used to see the "grainy" image mentioned.
When it comes to CDs and DVDs, the what you pay is what you get advice is the best advice to follow.
How long CDs last very much depends on the protective coating put on the CD and how well it is taken care of. In today's day with competition being so fierce in the CD industry, many companies cut costs on the CD by lowering the quality of the protective coating. The best advice if you want data on the CD to last a lifetime, buy a good name brand CD/DVD (if you have a hard time seeing the coating on the back of the CD, chances are there is not much of a coating there) and store it in an individual case or a dust free casing that holds multiple CDs individually.
Unfortunately, as easy as a memory card/flash disk is to transfer data, use it only for temporary storage not long time data storage. You will lose data much faster on a memory card or flash disk than you will data on a CD/DVD.
I have had pictures stored in my camera memory that "disappear" just a few months after they were taken. A flash disk stores data the longest if you frequently run a virus scan on it (this causes all the data on the flash disk to be refreshed) otherwise you will over time see some files starting to become unreadable. The newer flash disks nowadays are much more resistant to data storage losses then original flash disks that were created within the first 5 years of the technology.