Canada's Debt

niniveh

Well-known member
Jun 8, 2009
2,334
1,389
113

​

The Carney government plans to borrow unprecedented amounts in non-budgetary transactions that don’t inflate the deficit

The Editorial Board
The Globe and Mail
Published 6 hours agoUpdated 33 minutes ago
ETBDM4TAU5A7FJ7LQKHCDPSPSU.jpg

Illustration by Melanie Lambrick/The Globe and Mail
160 Comments
Share
Save for later
Give this article

The Carney Liberals are, despite bragging about their fiscal prudence, piling up debt at a rapid pace. Alarming as the growth of debt is within the bounds of the federal budget, it is not the full picture.

Behind that growing pile of borrowed funds is a shadow debt, what Ottawa calls “non-budgetary transactions.” It’s a catch-all category for outlays that are not, by the federal government’s budget rules, counted toward spending and therefore don’t add to the annual deficit.

But borrowed money is borrowed money. Whatever their nomenclature, outlays that are part of non-budgetary transactions – with the bland name of financial requirements – add to Ottawa’s debt servicing costs.

Until recently, non-budgetary transactions were just an asterisk in the federal budget, having little effect on the government’s financial picture. But the Carney government has started to push enormous sums toward non-budgetary transactions, creating a growing gap between the deficit and debt figures in the budget and what the government is actually borrowing and owes.

A picture of prudence gets blurry​

The Liberals’ preferred fiscal narrative is one of prudence. As this first chart shows, the federal deficit is forecast to contract slightly by the end of the decade, dropping to $52.9-billion in fiscal 2031 from $62.3-billion this year. (This year’s deficit is also significantly higher than last year’s, which at $39.3-billion came in much smaller than initially forecast.)


But the picture of prudence starts to blur once non-budgetary transactions are considered. Such transactions include a range of items outside the bounds of typical program spending, including adjustments to Ottawa’s employee pension obligations, non-financial assets and, most important, loans to enterprise Crown corporations. (That type of Crown corporation operates on a commercial basis and at arm’s-length from the federal government.)


For most of Ottawa’s fiscal history, non-budgetary transactions amounted to a wash, as this second chart shows. In most years, there was either a modest surplus or a small deficit for non-budgetary transactions. That was typically driven by changes in Ottawa’s employee pension obligations.

There were exceptions, most notably during the financial crisis of 2008-09, when the Conservative government bailed out automakers.

But the Carney government (and the Trudeau government, in its final years) has made such transactions a central part of its approach to budgeting.

As recently as fiscal 2022, non-budgetary transactions actually reduced the amount that Ottawa needed to borrow, by $5.9-billion. But in fiscal 2029, the Carney government is projecting that non-budgetary transactions will add $110.4-billion to its borrowing requirements.


Open this photo in gallery:


Justin Trudeau's government presented its final federal budget in April, 2024.Justin Tang/The Canadian Press
Loans, investments and advances to enterprise Crown corporations are driving that increase. The 2024 budget, the last of the Trudeau government, pegged the cost of such transactions at $5.7-billion for fiscal 2023.

This month’s budget, however, forecast much higher amounts for outlays to enterprise Crown corporations, peaking at $66.4-billion in fiscal 2029.

Unsurprisingly, the cost of the federal debt will rise sharply during this decade. The budget forecasts that debt servicing costs will hit $85.5-billion in fiscal 2031, up from $53.5-billion in fiscal 2026, the first full year of the Carney government. There are a number of factors contributing to that surge, but the borrowing prompted by off-budgetary transactions is most assuredly on the list.

Hefty as that borrowing is, it does not show up in the deficit. But if it were to be added, Ottawa’s fiscal outlook would be drastically different, as this third chart shows. When the budget balance and off-budgetary transactions add up to a positive number, the result is called a financial source. When it is a negative number – as current projections show – the result is called a financial requirement.


For a start, the shortfall in fiscal 2026 created by the budget deficit and the financial requirement from non-budgetary transactions nearly triples, to $103.9-billion. In fiscal 2028, that overall tally soars to $169-billion. Outside of the economic emergency of fiscal 2020-21, that would be the biggest such borrowing on record for Ottawa.

That is, to put it mildly, not a picture of fiscal restraint. Yet, the Carney government still makes that claim, based in large part on its projections of a decline in the deficit as a percentage of gross domestic product. As this final chart shows, the deficit is forecast to shrink to 1.3 per cent of GDP in fiscal 2031, an improvement from this year’s 1.8 per cent.


But an analysis from the Parliamentary Budget Officer released last week shows how great a shadow is cast by the debt from non-budgetary transactions. The government’s growing financial requirements create a far less flattering trend.

In the current fiscal year, the PBO projects that the government’s financial requirement will equal 4.4 per cent of GDP, a figure that is slated to grow to 4.8 per cent in fiscal 2028 before contracting somewhat by 2031, to 3.5 per cent.


The shortfalls from non-budgetary transactions aren’t included in the budget deficit, at least not initially. Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne can, and does, ignore them in asserting that the government is staying within the bounds of its (not terribly constraining) fiscal boundaries. But all of that debt must be financed.

However, loans to enterprise Crown corporations can eventually show up in Ottawa’s budget balance. Losses on those loans will tend to reduce the earnings of those Crown corporations, crimping that source of revenue for the federal government. Conversely, loans that boost the bottom line of enterprise Crown corporations will in turn boost Ottawa’s revenue. (And, again, the cost of borrowing for those transactions adds to the government’s annual debt servicing costs.)

The government has not provided a detailed accounting of what it expects from its increase to loans, investments and advances to enterprise Crown corporations. Just two of the budget’s 532 pages are devoted to non-budgetary transactions.

But there is a clue lurking elsewhere in the budget. Income from enterprise Crown corporations is projected to nearly double from fiscal 2026 to fiscal 2031, rising from $13.1-billion to $26.1-billion. That’s consistent with Ottawa’s big influx of cash boosting profits at enterprise Crown corporations.


And that would create a most helpful trend for Ottawa, in which borrowing needed for non-budgetary transactions doesn’t push the budget deficit higher – but the returns from that borrowing later reduce the deficit.

No accounting rules are being broken. But the way that the Carney government is playing within those rules creates a fiscal uplift worth billions of dollars a year.

Open this photo in gallery:


Prime Minister Mark Carney and Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne arrive at the House of Commons in Ottawa to present the 2026 federal budget on Nov. 5.Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press

Shining a light on the shadow debt​

Whatever the accounting niceties, it is clear that the Liberals’ unprecedented embrace of non-budgetary transactions is rapidly making the traditional deficit a less than useful measure of the government’s fiscal situation.

Kevin Lynch, a former Clerk of the Privy Council and former deputy minister of Finance, has argued that the annual borrowing requirement is the better measure.

That is correct, in our view. The Carney government may have its reasons for veering so far from budgetary norms but, in doing so, it has distorted the fiscal picture too greatly. A focus on the annual borrowing requirement would bring that debt trend out of the shadows and into the clear view of Canadians.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Squeeler