King V or Randy Rhoads????

Hockey_MLnut

Go Ahead Make My Day
Aug 2, 2004
1,139
0
36
Scarborough
I am looking to buy a new guitar and I am have a hard time deciding between these two Jacksons.

Just wanted to know the opinions of the guitar players on the board.

King V with Blue or Black ghost flame finish
Or
Randy Rhoads edition with cherry red finish.



Thanks everyone
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,870
242
63
Doesn't it depend on the type of sound you are going for?

E.g. a les paul is a great guitar but no good for someone looking for that single coil sound.

There are so many variables that make buying a guitar a very personal choice.

In addition to sound..... what about things like thickness of the neck. If you have hendrix like hands no problem..... but if you have angus young hands a smaller neck will suit you better.

What about purpose...... are you planning on playing for hours on your feet? Might want one that you can comfortably carry for a long time.

If you play sitting down then you want one that sits in your lap comfortably.

Sorry I was speaking more generally after looking at the Jackson homepage I can see that both are very similar guitars.

I cut and pasted the specs from the jackson homepage

King V has 2 less frets but you can control which pickups are on. Also, the King V has 2 pickups vs one.

I don't know enough about neck construction but to some that makes a huge difference. Also the types of wood used in making the guitar also make a difference to some people.

If I'm reading this info right I think the king V will be a bit more versatile in the sounds you can get given that it has more controls over the pickups.

But I'm no means an expert nor am I a good player so take my input for what it's worth..... a casual fan of guitars.

25th Anniversary King V™
Body Poplar
Neck 3-Piece Neck-Thru-Body Quartersawn Maple (No Scarf Joint)
Neck Dimensions 3rd Fret: .775”, 12th Fret: .835”
Tuning Machines Gotoh® Die-Cast Tuners
Fingerboard Ebony
No. of Frets 22 Jumbo Frets
Bridge Pickup Seymour Duncan® JB™ TB4 Humbucking Pickup
Middle Pickup N/A
Neck Pickup Seymour Duncan® Jazz™ SH2N Humbucking Pickup
Controls Volume (Bridge Pickup),
Volume (Neck Pickup),
Master Tone
Bridge Floyd Rose® Original™ Double Locking 2-Point Tremolo
Pickup Switching 3-Position Blade:
Position 1. Bridge Pickup
Position 2. Bridge and Neck Pickups
Position 3. Neck Pickup
Hardware Black
Strings NPS, XL, (.009 to .042)
Case Includes Deluxe Molded Case
Pickguard None
Scale Length 25.5”
Width at Nut 1-11/16”
Notice Product Prices, Features And Specifications Are Subject To Change Without Notice
Unique Features Compound (12” to 16”) Fingerboard Radius,
Mother of Pearl Shark Fin Position Inlays,
Ivoroid Bound Fingerboard and Headstock,
Jackson King V Original Body Shape and Size,
3-Piece Maple Neck (No Scarf Joint),
Ivoroid Binding on Neck and headstock,
Mother-of-Pearl Shark Fin Position Inlays,
Vintage Correct Specs Including ,80s Decal Logo,
Floyd Rose R3 Nut,
CTS® Pots and Switchcraft® Switches
Introduced 1/2005




Pro Series RR24 Rhoads™
Body Alder
Neck Neck-Thru-Body Rock Maple with Scarf Joint Head Stock
Neck Dimensions 3rd Fret: .790”, 12th Fret: .850”
Tuning Machines Sealed Die-Cast Tuners
Fingerboard Ebony with Compound 14” to 16” Radius
No. of Frets 24 Jumbo Frets
Bridge Pickup EMG® 81
Middle Pickup N/A
Neck Pickup N/A
Controls Volume
Bridge Floyd Rose® Original™ Double Locking 2-Point Tremolo
Pickup Switching None
Hardware Black
Strings NPS, Gauges:
.009, .011, .016, .024, .032, .042
Case Optional Deluxe Molded Case
Pickguard None
Scale Length 25.5” (648mm)
Width at Nut 1-11/16” (43mm)
Notice Product Prices, Features And Specifications Are Subject To Change Without Notice
Unique Features 24 Jumbo Frets,
1 EMG® 81 Pickup,
Jackson 6-In-Line Pointed Headstock,
Compound (14” to 16”) Fingerboard Radius,
MOTO Shark Fin Position Inlays,
Introduced 1/2007
:: Close Window
 

a 1 player

Smells like manly roses.
Feb 24, 2004
9,722
9
0
on your girlfriend
In short, the best way to buy a guitar is to go to the store and try some until you find one that has the sound and feel that you like. You might be surprised with what you discover.

I really wanted a Les Paul, had my heart set on one. Just as I was about to purchase it, I saw a PRS (Paul Reed Smith) that tweaked my curiosity. Tried it for 5 minutes and changed my mind. 10 times the comfort and versatility.

Just something to ponder.
 

Eli

New member
May 25, 2005
1,637
0
0
I saw go for an original Gibson Flying V or a Les Pual custom.
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,870
242
63
Eli said:
I saw go for an original Gibson Flying V or a Les Pual custom.
Big difference in price between a Jackson V and a vintage Gibson V! The Les Paul Custom is not really a big deal other than having a 3rd pick up..... more for collectors than anything else. :D

I don't think Slash should be on that list of guys with their own sound..... in that he's a les paul and marshall man..... nothing too original about that.
 

jbar

New member
Jun 4, 2006
1,115
0
0
You will also want to GREATLY consider based on the pick-ups (if you are not inclined to swap the stock ones). The Seymours are passive pickups and have generally been used by players like RATT and bands of that ilk. They have also been used by the players in Halford. They are generally set-up for 80's style metal (e.g. eq-voicing, and timbre). I'm not too much of an expert on Seymours.. I'm a DiMarzio man myself.

The EMG 81s are active pickups (require a battery - 800 of playing life), that the heavier bands/players are using. For example: Slayer, Metallica, Zakk Wylde, Judas Priest, Blind Guardian. These pick-ups are ultra-high output (1750 millivolts, about 5 times higher than the Seymours), and produce a very compressed, sterile tone that doesn't reflect the tonal qualities of the wood of whatever guitar you are playing (they are famous for it). You could slap that pickup into a $50 Sears guitar and it would sound pretty much the same as a $4000 guitar with that same pick-up.


Also, the body woods (alder vs poplar) are not that different in terms of tonal quality. They are both about halfway between Mahogany (dark) and Maple (bright) on the eq scale. Fender Strats, and Steve Vai's white Ibanez Jem are made from Alder. And physically, if weight matters to you, a poplar guitar is about a pound heavier than a same guitar made from alder.




Lastly, like the others have said on this thread, tone and comfort is subjective, so go try them out. Steve's Music on Queen Street West usually has a decent number of Jacksons that you can try out. If you let them know that your serious about buying, then they will be of great service and will let you fiddle to your hearts content.


Cheers
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,870
242
63
Hey Jbar,

Great info!

But I am strongly against Steve's Music. I prefer Songbird and Time Capsule which are both on Queen West mind you I prefer to gawk at all the pretty vintage guitars that these places sell rather than the brand new off the racks that Steve's provides.

Not to mention you can find things like Bogner Amps/Cabs and other cool high end equipment at these places.

Any thoughts on how to spend $1000? Not sure how much the Jackson's go for but let's say for arguments sake that they go for $1000 new. What about spending that $1000 on a vintage guitar that will hold it's value rather than a brand new guitar which will depreciate the second you take it out of the store?

In my opinion the Jackson guitars are more of a fashion statement than instruments of really high quality. As opposed to say Fender, Gibson, PRS...... mind you Fenders and Gibsons run the full spectrum in prices.
 

Hockey_MLnut

Go Ahead Make My Day
Aug 2, 2004
1,139
0
36
Scarborough
I love both of these guitars I have played them at the store and also have played one of my friends King V.

The sound of both of these guitars is one that I really like.
 

jbar

New member
Jun 4, 2006
1,115
0
0
frankcastle said:
Hey Jbar,

Great info!

But I am strongly against Steve's Music. I prefer Songbird and Time Capsule which are both on Queen West mind you I prefer to gawk at all the pretty vintage guitars that these places sell rather than the brand new off the racks that Steve's provides.

Not to mention you can find things like Bogner Amps/Cabs and other cool high end equipment at these places.

Any thoughts on how to spend $1000? Not sure how much the Jackson's go for but let's say for arguments sake that they go for $1000 new. What about spending that $1000 on a vintage guitar that will hold it's value rather than a brand new guitar which will depreciate the second you take it out of the store?

In my opinion the Jackson guitars are more of a fashion statement than instruments of really high quality. As opposed to say Fender, Gibson, PRS...... mind you Fenders and Gibsons run the full spectrum in prices.
No problem. I'll comment on your comments/questions one at a time.

a) I've been to both Song and Time Capsule in order to compare their prices with Steve's, (on the products that I have been interested in) and Steve's prices are been better. Also, Steve's music has treated me well (since I have been a half-decent customer) by giving me further discounts and freebies. However, I do agree with your observation that these smaller places carry much more unique/weird guitars, but they are not really my taste.

b) I can't even beginning to think about bringing in half-stacks and full-stacks into my 1 bedroom apartment. Even a 25-watt tube amp would upset the neighbors since tube-amps need to be cranked in order to reach their proper distortion limits. And I'm not necessary looking for high-end equipment...I'm looking for bang for the buck. Case in point: I have an Ibanez RG320FM (a $450 beginner model made in Indonesia, but I upgraded the pickups to DiMarzios) and have been lusting after a RGA121VLF (a $1,150 professional-level model made in Japan) for a few months now. Last week, someone from another forum advised me that a store in North Bay (called Acclaim Electronics) was having a clearance on them for $850. I ordered it on Monday, and it is being delivered as we speak. Normally, spending $850 on an Ibanez RG would get you an intermediate level RG (built in Korea). So what I got was a top-level RG for a mid-level price. God bless capitalism. Case in point #2: I also bought a Dean Z 79 re-issue (Explorer type-body with a Brazilia-burst color) a year ago since I was looking for a Gibson-type guitar for the stuff I don’t play on my RG. After comparing it to a Gibson Explorer (among other cheaper guitars of the same style), I found that the Dean was a better-built (and classier looking) guitar for less money than the Gibson ($650 verses $950). The Dean was better reviewed by many sources, and Dean is a large-scale boutique manufacturer as opposed to Gibson, which means different marketing strategies, manufacturing processes, quality-control, general operations, etc…. Oh, and I hate Les-Pauls.

c) My thoughts on how to spend $1000, see immediately above (e.g. my new RGA). Ha! Seriously though, I’m not too knowledgeable about Jackson pricing and quality scales (ask me about Ibanez and Dean), but here are my assumptions based on my minimal research on this company:
-Entry-level: $0-$700, made in China (I could be wrong on the country)
-Intermediate level: $700-$2000, made in Korea
-Professional level: $2000-$4000, made in USA
-Custom shop: $4000-?????, made in USA (one-off specialty orders)
I was actually thinking about buying a $1000 mid-level Jackson, a nice red DKMGT (with a EMG 81 in the bridge and a 85 in the neck – both stock, as opposed to the cheapie EMG HZ pickups from last year), but the RGA deal came up instead. I was thinking about the Jackson because of the EMG active pickups that come stock with it. Ibanez has a mid-level RG (around $1000) that has those same EMG’s, but the Ibanez comes in black only (which I don’t like). Being that I am in this hobby for entertainment purposes, and my guitars will be buried with me, I have no problems buying a guitar that is right for me (regardless of cost). I’m not in this for investment purposes. I’d rather buy a $1000 guitar that has a $500 book value (a year down the road) that is comfortable to play, than buy a $1000 guitar that has a $800 book value (a year down the road) that is uncomfortable to play. I’m not a serious collector, and not %100 informed on what the actual market is doing in terms of book values. But what I do know is that buying vintage doesn’t guarantee a return on investment, most of the time an old piece of crap is still an old piece of crap. In short, what ever you think the best guitar is for $1000, then that’s your guitar. The only thing I can give an opinion about on guitars is product attributes. But, if I HAD to give a personal opinion on collectible guitars, and choose one, I would suggest small companies that hand build guitars exclusively like Lado in Scarborough. Their website has extensive information on their company and manufacturing processes.

d) Many guitar fashion statements are made buy many guitar companies. I do agree that Jackson maybe a tad one-dimensional in that %95 of it’s product line caters to the heavy-metal crowd. But pretty much every guitar manufacturer produces instruments of tremendous quality… the key is to identify the country of manufacture. Here is what I have found on the Ibanez RG-series and Dean Z-series:
-Entry-Level: Indonesia (Ibanez), China (Dean)
-Intermediate-Level: Korea (both)
-Professional-Level: Japan (Ibanez), USA (Dean)
Lastly, I’ve tried-out Fenders, which are not my style (I don’t like 3-pickup designs, the fretboard is nowhere as fast as Ibanez fretboards, I don’t like single coil pickups, etc..), and Gibsons, which are over-hyped (in my opinion) and cost too much for what they are (hence my Dean purchase).



Cheers
 

jbar

New member
Jun 4, 2006
1,115
0
0
Hockey_MLnut said:
I love both of these guitars I have played them at the store and also have played one of my friends King V.

The sound of both of these guitars is one that I really like.
If you like both, then buy both. Each one is different enough to justify it (in my mind..ha!). If you can't swing buying both at the same time, then try financing them (e.g. monthly payments for 3 years), or try the used market (but be careful).


Cheers
 

frankcastle

Well-known member
Feb 4, 2003
17,870
242
63
Yeah I hear ya my friend has some seriously expensive and hard to find vintage guitars made by gretch, fender, and gibson along with amps and cabs by marshall, fender and hi watt but at the same time he really likes the Ibanez Artist..... along with some old Silvertone guitars.

There certainly is a place for the cheaper guitars out there.
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts