Every review is incredibly subjective no matter what the source. You could have a great time with a SP because of some instant chemistry on a very personal level. I've had a few experiences where I did have an awesome experience but said nothing at all about the girl, because we clicked in a way where I felt it would be hard to recreate with other personalities. You know when the first few minutes is like pulling teeth, but all of a sudden you find some obscure common ground that breaks the ice and then it takes a 180?
There's also going to be people new to the hobby that haven't got the experience to know the difference between good and goooood. I was no different when I started...if a girl was pretty and I could fuck her, that was amazing! But there's more to it than that. There's one very well reviewed girl over there that I found extremely pleasant to be with and is a total knockout...but the naked part I found dull. Of course there's raves about her skills, but I didn't find that at all, just average. Not going through the motions, but not passionate either. I wouldn't say anything bad about her, but there was nothing to write home about. Some guys just see her body and lose their shit because to them it's like fucking a porn star and that's what they want.
I like dummpy's take....you start communicating with them and you get a feel for what they're like. Every time I have a good feeling about a girl before I meet her I'm never disappointed, and I've never had a good time with someone that I had reservations about when dealing with them beforehand. Intuition is a good thing. There was a recent addition there that looked promising so I contacted her and she seemed completely retarded. Fuck that, lots of other girls out there that own a brain. Maybe she's fucks like nobody's business, but I'll take my chances...
But the other board is good and has far more info and opportunity to get to know the girls than here. Without the censorship, the ladies wouldn't play. This board is moderated too, don't forget that...just not to the same degree.