Julian Fantino would not know a civil right if it beat him over the head. He was more effective than many police chiefs, and perhaps more honest. But the idea that you can't just treat everyone like a criminal, whether they are or not, and that respecting people's rights is also important, just totally escaped him. I am all for real criminals being punished and not having too many rights. But allowing police officers to convict and punish people on the spot is not right.
I think he more than anyone is responsible for the 150 super punishments, he intimidated them into passing the law. I am not crazy about it, but it does seem to have been very effective. If they are telling the truth about the accident rates.