The GM name drags the value down.
I took a look at the Saturn Astre and decieded to buy a Canadian made Japanese car. The Astre europe has a good reputation in Europe, and they even use it as police cars in the UK. I liked the car, and it handled well. In the end it was better for me to buy a Ontario made Japanese car, it will keep its value much better over the 5 years I plan to keep it, it will be cheaper to maintain, and it will bring me better resale value when I trade it. As a low use second car, it is a better choice for me. The Astre will loose value just because it is sold in so small numbers in Canada, and it has the GM name on it. I must say, my impressions are, the Astre is almost a VW.