Here's three slightly lower profile celebrity women that I can honestly say I find attractive, yet I doubt many others would.
Cynthia Stevenson - not that I've watched many of the movies or bad sitcoms she's been in.
Sarah Silverman - kind of cute looking and sounding, incongruous with the outrageous and sometimes offensive things that she says.
Jann Karam - another comedienne.
Others I'm sure some guys do find attractive:
Someone I haven't seen listed yet, Aisha Tyler - former 'Talk Soup' host. And the previously mentioned Peri Gilpin, from Frasier and the shampoo commercial - even her voice is sexy. And Jan Smithers - anyone else remember seeing her be introduced for the swimming race part of one of those dumb 'Battle of the Network Stars' things, where they had given the women one-piece swimsuits that weren't completely opaque in the sunlight?