Like the Ducks, or the Hurricane, or ......
Or, the Jays in baseball. I'd rather have a team that shows up every year than one that wins every thirty years then disappears.
Anyway, the flaw with your argument is that it's predicated upon declining returns. Frankly, I'm not sure that's the case with this squad. I think you can safely predict more injury woes, but quite possibly not as many man-games lost as last year. If you look at the numbers, they don't show any decline for any of the Leafs veterans.
They've discarded Renberg and Reichel which are significant changes up front.
Who should they add?
I did NOT "minimize" their chances. I said they were probably the fourth seed coming out of the east. That's a decent shot.
I think that will be upgraded with a full season from Leetch and the solidification of the Leaf defense - that is, what to do with Kaberle, and Marchment for that matter - and better overall production up front.
No team is *ever* "the best they can do". I think Roberts and Nieuwendyk were decent signings at a reasonable price. I'll say again that I don't think anyone else with that production who's significantly younger than those two would come at anywhere near that price.
What FA's out there are in the Leafs' price range, without signing Berg, Roberts, and Nieuwendyk? ...... I'd guess not many, and not many that would "put them over the top".
The only real problem I have is with the cash they threw at Belfour. Unfortunately, they were between a rock and a hard place. Tellqvist has NOT developed as they'd anticipated, so without resigning Belfour, there just wasn't anyone. Weekes? WAY too big a gamble with such a veteran team - career-suicide for young Ferguson if that one didn't work out.
Sure, he's playing it safe. Safe gave them a Cup run last year, and one which saw them bounce one of the consensus favourites. It's hard to predict, going into the season, who's going to be favoured. The Leafs will be in the mix, as they were last year. If they finish first - distinctly possible - I'd say they'd be the odds-on favourites to go to the Finals.