Vaughan Spa

legalities and the new change in prostition laws

Aardvark154

New member
Jan 19, 2006
53,761
3
0
Again it doesn't matter whether it's private. It matters whether it's a private place.
That is a related but not necessarily the same issue.

Clearly we know that calling an sp from a cell phone that can be overheard in let us say Union Station is not wise.

The question however is if that conversation is intercepted (it does after all travel by radio wave) is it private as is a wired conversation or not, being rather like that call from Union Station even if you make the call from entirely private place. This by now is beating a dead horse, since my question merely is this a question that the SCC has directly answered.
 

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,966
8
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
That is a related but not necessarily the same issue.

Clearly we know that calling an sp from a cell phone that can be overheard in let us say Union Station is not wise.

The question however is if that conversation is intercepted (it does after all travel by radio wave) is it private as is a wired conversation or not, being rather like that call from Union Station even if you make the call from entirely private place. This by now is beating a dead horse, since my question merely is this a question that the SCC has directly answered.
You could pick up a ham radio and communicate for the purposes of prostitution and broadcast it to half the country, and it still wouldn't matter, because a radio wave is not a place. Similarly, and obviously more commonly, you can post ads for prostitutes in newspapers and in public online forums like terb or craigslist, and it's not illegal because neither a newspaper nor terb is a place, even though both are (somewhat) public.

It helps to remember that the purpose of the communications law is not to stamp out prostitution entirely, but rather, prevent it from interfering with people on the street, and other public places, who are going about their ordinary business. It's targeted at "red light" areas where prostitutes line the streets and flag every car that goes by. That's why the law references a "place".
 

Anynym

Just a bit to the right
Dec 28, 2005
2,959
6
38
I'm not about to recite the litany of your posts.

But no place in that article does it even offer an opinion on the legal definition of "place", let alone support your contention that the question has been settled by the courts. Where is your citation for the legal definition of "place" in the relevant sections of the CCC?
 
Toronto Escorts