Public or Private BCL

Should the BCL be private or public???

  • private

    Votes: 28 58.3%
  • public

    Votes: 16 33.3%
  • don't care

    Votes: 4 8.3%

  • Total voters
    48

HappyHookers

New member
Feb 2, 2005
266
0
0
I have been asked to bring this poll here as TERB is the largest board in our area right now. Many people on other sites are going on about Private vs. public lists. I have address the comments made on SPOC site below so that has just been copied over here. Most of what I have said can be address to Paige from BBE as well, but let me add on more little thing here. A person, bad client or not, has the right to privacy. I know most will say that they have no right if they hurt someone, but in reality they do. If someone has raped and robbed an SP and we have his name, home address, phone number, work contact, the whole internet world does not need to know it. Now while the SPOC has clearly stated that their lawyer will handle any complaints from men listed, I am quite sure they haven't actually had complaints as of yet. Not only that, but having such a small list may have an affect on this. If they or BBE were to publish the list I have, I can tell you all now, there would be problems. To make things fair I have included statements from BBE and SPOC about this as quoted from their sites. While I understand this is A LOT of reading, I do encourage you to take the extra time, read the posts and make your vote known.
 
As quoted from BBE:

Some believe that a Secret Bad Client List, hidden away on some board where only those who are given access by the administrator can benefit from it, is safer than one that is out in the open for ALL service providers to see.

Some escorts believe that if hobbyists have access to such a list, they will "learn" from that how to harm the ladies... that the list teaches men how to harm SPs and then they'll go out and become copy cats.

I disagree. Those who want to hurt the ladies, will. Period. Nobody needs to teach them how to. In my opinion, Secret Bad Client Lists protect the dangerous clients, not the ladies.

The real "bad clients" know they are just that, and will change things about themselves automatically after they've harmed someone... ie their hair, beard, clothing, contact info, etc. I also believe these creeps should be exposed for what they are in a public forum for everyone to see, so that we can all work together to weed them out of the industry and keep the ladies safer.

If someone in the general public commits a crime, is it not reported on the news so everyone can be informed, aware, and take proper precautions until the person is caught?? They don't protect the criminals by reporting the crime on some secret channel somewhere, where only a select few have access or even know about it. Yes, certain details that only the perpetrator would know are kept away from the public, but that's for the police to use in order to assist them in catching the real criminal and arresting the right person.

It's a myth that if you keep the list secret, it'll somehow protect the ladies. I think the opposite happens... it protects the dangerous client, and does squat for the ladies who do not have access to the list. Also, the "good" hobbyists may be able to assist if they too know who's on the list. Maybe one of the guys is someone he's befriended in the hobby, not knowing what he's really like with the ladies.

That is why I promote SPOC here and encourage anyone who has been harmed by a client to contact them. It's completely confidential. Your name is never mentioned anywhere.

Now, that's MY explanation for why the Bad Client List on this board is out in the open. But, I would like to hear from the rest of you. What do you think and why?
 
The real "bad clients" know they are just that, and will change things about themselves automatically after they've harmed someone... ie their hair, beard, clothing, contact info, etc. I also believe these creeps should be exposed for what they are in a public forum for everyone to see, so that we can all work together to weed them out of the industry and keep the ladies safer.

Naming them publicly is not going to weed them out, it is going to drive them underground. They will then go for people who are not online, escorts who only advertise in papers, or who are streetwalkers. They will make sure that the women they see do not have access to the list.


If someone in the general public commits a crime, is it not reported on the news so everyone can be informed, aware, and take proper precautions until the person is caught?? They don't protect the criminals by reporting the crime on some secret channel somewhere, where only a select few have access or even know about it. Yes, certain details that only the perpetrator would know are kept away from the public, but that's for the police to use in order to assist them in catching the real criminal and arresting the right person.

Not all case, not even half the case are made public. Not only that, but most of the case that are discussed have elements of the case private. Police will ensure that details are left out of the public media. They do this for a reason. Also the person who commit the crime, his work number, and address, home number and address, home phone, work phone, cell phone, email address etc are not given. Even when Roger {Who’s last name was not given to the media} was being sought after, the media gave a small amount of information. The private BCL on TAD had more information then the media did.

It's a myth that if you keep the list secret, it'll somehow protect the ladies. I think the opposite happens... it protects the dangerous client, and does squat for the ladies who do not have access to the list. Also, the "good" hobbyists may be able to assist if they too know who's on the list. Maybe one of the guys is someone he's befriended in the hobby, not knowing what he's really like with the ladies.

Anyone who can access the BCL on SPOC and BBE can access the BCL on HHC or other private lists as well. And while it would be nice to get information from “good” hobbyist. It is not acceptable. The information should really only come from the ladies who have been involved. I know some are going to ask why? It is simple, black listing someone is not easy, it is not a matter of making a post and then forgetting about it. I know to most it must seem that way, but truly it is not. You have to be almost 100% that they information you are listing is truthful, and accurate. No one really knows about who is who on these boards. Look at the Tatiana crap on BBE and *****. Also most of the people on the list are not known by their handles. We don’t do the handle thing, we get the real info. We have to. We will list known names, usernames etc, but that is not what we go by, so how is any “good” hobbyist seriously going to be able to help us. Maybe once or twice out of the hundred or so that is listed.

con't
 
As quoted from SPOC:

FROM SPOC.CA NEWS

ITEM # 3
FEBRUARY, 25 /2004

There has been some discussion around the GTA recently about the content of the Bad Date List on this site. Some sex pro's, (from other sites), are concerned that by posting identifying info about bad dates so publicly, the guys may then change their M.O.'s, such as Internet handles, switch hotels they stay at or use different phone numbers etc.

On every other site we have been to in order to access bad date info, you must be a member of the site, with a password, confirmation e-mail and usually have to prove you are a sex pro.

On this site all you need to have access to any part of the site is a computer and Internet access.

We at spoc believe that info about violent or potentially violent clients should be available to all sex pro's, all the time. In fact this info should be available to anyone who may have any kind of relationship with these men.

Many sex pro's aren't interested in dealing with passwords etc., and many cannot "prove" they are in the business.

Permitting only a small number of escorts this potentially life saving info, ends up protecting bad dates.

Our goal is to protect as many sex pro's as possible. Bad date info is not about ownership of the people collecting it and no one should have to join a club in order to gain access to info about violent and potentially dangerous men.

As for bad dates changing their M.O's, they do that anyway. Just because the info is on a private site doesn't mean he won't try to deceive in new ways as a matter of course.

Also it is more difficult and time consuming for them to change real names, land line numbers, real addresses and appearance. Soon whenever we have a photo of a violent bad date we will post it on this site.

We would like to encourage a lively, but civilized debate about this. Pro or con we'll post people's ideas on this page. Everyone's ideas will be posted anonymously of course.

Our e-mail is vscott@spoc.ca
 
The only question I have is who serves as judge and jury? On a "public" list, you need to be damned sure that your info is correct, or possibly be faced with defamation of character lawsuits galore.
 
I personally have some problems with what I have quoted above and if you ladies will bare with me I will explain why. I feel it is important to do so because the BCL on this site will be private and password protected. I have taken out the parts that I would like to address from the statement written in full above.

Many sex pro's aren't interested in dealing with passwords etc., and many cannot "prove" they are in the business.

As a sex professional, I am use to dealing with passwords. For my email, my website, to access my computer, for boards, affiliate programs, banner exchanges, etc. A password for BCL doesn't seem to be that much more of a hassle for the security that we are getting. And as for proving that we are actually workers. It is not as hard as you may think. Since this is a website, most who are on here have actually sites, or some sort of online advertising. If they don't happen to advertise online, they have an ad in a paper, which is easy enough to find. Now for SW, it might be a little different, but I can say that more then half of the SW's out there are not online, so then an online BCL is not useful to them anyways. I don't think it right for one group women to suffer possible danger because of another group of working women that are not able to use the service that BCL provides.

We at SPOC believe that info about violent or potentially violent clients should be available to all sex pro's, all the time. In fact this info should be available to anyone who may have any kind of relationship with these men.

While I agree that woman all around the world should be able to be safe from harm, I again don't see how a public list is going to help women who A) are not sex professionals just happen to be the mother, daughter, wife of a person listed and B) women who do not have online access so they can't read the information provided, but it is available for the man.


As for bad dates changing their Mo.’s, they do that anyway. Just because the info is on a private site doesn't mean he won't try to deceive in new ways as a matter of course.

This one I truly don't understand. If you target women in this business, you study them online, and you know there is a public BCL, you think the man is not going to check what is known about him for the sole purpose of changing it. I can also say for fact that one person who was listed as an undesirable on the SPOC did change his phone number that he books with, the email address he uses and username that he went by. He did that because it was brought to his attention on GTAC that he was listed on the SPOC site. We have his current information.

Also, and you can confirm this with any police detective, most offenders do not change their MO until they feel they must, and even then they usually only change names and numbers, but their personality and demeanor don't change. If you saw your contact info on a site for Bad dates, you would feel you had to change your MO. We can match up new contact info,but it is the men who see we can track them because they always "ask for this" or always "order that" or look for certain types of women, or only contact women via certain advertising medias, that will change everything they can about them to book that next call, or worse, they won't change anything about them,but instead just change where they find their new girl from and you can be sure he will pick a woman he knows is resourceful enough to use a BCL.

Also it is more difficult and time consuming for them to change real names, land line numbers, real addresses and appearance. Soon whenever we have a photo of a violent bad date we will post it on this site.

I know of many women who have been in this business for a long time who do not get all that information. I also know many new comers who doesn't know what info to get from a client. Some women perform incalls so they have no real address. Some emn book through hotels, no address there, and some men book through Motels where no ID is required. Cell phones are simple with pay-as-you-go phones. A new SIM card is only about $25, it is easy to cancel one number and get another. Emails address, are even easier. Appearance I will agree to a point, but how many men do you know are white, 6 foot, about 180lb-200lbs, with short brown hair, brown eyes. Even add smoker, drug user, heavy drinker, suit and tie wearer. And while photos will help, how many entries into the list are going to come with photos. And unless the man has a tattoo or scar that is identifying, it is really hard to tell anything by a description.

con't....
 
Our goal is to protect as many sex pro's as possible. Bad date info is not about ownership of the people collecting it and no one should have to join a club in order to gain access to info about violent and potentially dangerous men.

This is not a club that you are joining, women do not even have to be members of this board to access the password protected area that the BCL will be under, but they do have to contact me for access. Also does SPOC feel that best way to protect women is just by listing entries that they get, and have some protests and awareness seminars? To my understanding the BCL is suppose to be a collective list of information regarding dates that SP’s have seen and have had difficulty with ranging from dangerous and violent acts made against them, to men who are pushy, rough, drunk, drugged and everything in between. Maybe I am wrong in thinking this way.

I would like to open the floor to a friendly discussion on your opinions of whether a BCL should be private or public. While I may disagree with some of the views of the SPOC and BBE on this matter, I still respect that their intentions are good.

I am not trying to mean any disrespect in any way about this. I am just hoping to get the opinions of women I know use a BCL on a regular basis.

HH
 
as an escort & IMO

i think the bcl should remain private for only us to see. it is there to protect us not for clients to go read as they are not the ones who have to see these men. any board that does give bcl info out to the general public is not posting it in the best interest of the escort stripper or mpa, they are doing so to boost membership as is one of the boards you have listed in this thread.

i am all for pro hobbiest but not at the cost of someone getting hurt and the bcl was set up for us to protect our selves. :(


PS if escorts really want to black list someone they will do so via pm or email there is no need to do so on the bcl
 
Last edited:
A private mens room is not keeping anyone safe.

A BCL whether private or public is not a "club" like a private mens room is.

I've read this thrown in every time a private BCL is brought up and it's literally comparing apples to oranges.
 
IMHO a public BCL will give bad clients the ability to become even more nefarious in their ways. Bad clients will know they've been listed and may choose subterfuge when trying to book a session and in the worst case, will succeed in getting an SP to come over.

Additionally, as Goober mentions a public BCL can lead to certain legal wranglings which likely aren't worth the effort. It's possible that a BCL is not entirely legal (much like this hobby we all enjoy). If so, a court challenge could lead to ta banning of the BCL - obviously not something we wish to see.
 
Bad clients lists must be private to be effective because the only way an escort can identify a reported bad client in advance is through private information: verified name, phone number, address, etc.

No reporting system is perfect and pure, and so it would be an egregious violation to publish such information publicly. I've run a bad client list, and there were times when I saw people reported who I knew to be okay clients, but perhaps had a confrontation with a specific SP.

Over this past weekend, a good friend of mine was stood up at the last minute for an overnight session. She was very disappointed -- and I can see her point. How difficult would it have been for the customer to pick up the phone and let her know that it wasn't going to happen? Why let her make all kinds of arrangements and never even bother to let her know that it wasn't necessary?

But even though I 'm sure she was furious enough to report him to a Bad Clients' List over the weekend, is he a truly bad client? Maybe not. Both she and I have seen him a number of times in the past, and he was always a good client to date. The argument could be made that, by giving her account of what happened, it would give other escorts a heads-up for dealing with him in the future (especially if she included the fact that he has never presented any problems for 1-hour appointments). But on the other hand, if it meant putting his personal information out there in public, then no -- I don't think it would be worth it.

Also, I think that if bad client lists become public, then it will inhibit customers from wanting to verify. Verification is crucial to escorts' safety and security. There are many reasons for wanting to be anonymous -- one might be discretion, but others include that the "customer" wants to remain unaccountable for various types of bad behaviour.

It's better for us to protect client privacy -- even in the case of bad clients, by keeping it private -- than to discourage clients from verifying so SPs can feel safe.

..c..
 
I'm curious about who will make the decision. Is a poll going to influence one persons mind if it's already made up?
 
We completely support a private Bad Client List.

We are in the middle of letting our ads on the RedZone expire because they have a banner on BBE. We will not support advertising venues who support a website that allows a public BCL and anonymous reviews. More escorts are doing the same.
For us we also advertise the RedZone urls in our (Sun) ads. Way may lose at the beginning ... but I think in the long run it will be more beneficial to advertisers to put our money where we feel it will be respected.
When I say "we" ... I mean ... Flora, Hailey, Lindsay, Jules, Jessica, Raven, Molly, Candy, Crystal and of course Sierra.


Amber

PS ... we are currently looking to advertise your (easy) url with our webpage ... like for example https://terb.cc/flora (hint hint). ;)
 
luv4lust said:
bcl shouldn't be used for no shows that info can be given out in pm :rolleyes:

You may think so, but not all escorts using a bad clients' list may agree. When I ran such a list, I had escorts reporting guys for bad hygiene and "being weird" -- which are the sort of things I'd (and many other escorts would) turn a client down for.

Other escorts reported clients for giving them bad reviews. (which, again, is reasonable)

And still others reported clients for arguing with them over the services they were entitled to receive for the money they paid.

So it's not so cut-&-dried. Bad clients, like beauty, are in the eye of the beholder. All any contributor can do is give her account and let the chips fall where they may -- and to some degree, the account she gives will be weighted by the validation the communiyty gives to her. Much the same as it is with escort reviews.


But for a bad client list to be effective, some degree of private information must be included in the report. (Reports such as "guy said his name was 'John', blue eyes, medium brown hair, 5'8"-5'10", medium build' are not really helpful for escorts hoping to avoid bad dates.

Verification information is crucial to being secure and avoiding bad dates.

Much like escort reviews, the quality of any BC listing depends upon the reputation of the SP making the report. If the SP is not regarded by her peers to be reliable, then the report carries much less weight. As with escort reviews, bad client reports depend on escorts having some knowledge and assessment of the person making the complaint.

If an escort who is esteemed among her peers notes that a client no-showed on her, I believe it would carry substantial weight. Much more so than if someone who wasn't known or wasn't esteemed would bear.

..c..
 
Bad hygiene?
A no-show will make the bad client list?
He'll be on par with someone who beats or rapes an escort?
 
T-Boob said:
If someone in the general public commits a crime, is it not reported on the news so everyone can be informed, aware, and take proper precautions until the person is caught?? They don't protect the criminals by reporting the crime on some secret channel somewhere, where only a select few have access or even know about it. Yes, certain details that only the perpetrator would know are kept away from the public, but that's for the police to use in order to assist them in catching the real criminal and arresting the right person.

Ah, no.

If someone in the general public is charged with a crime, it may be reported on the news. Of course, a charge only occurs after an investigation by the police. While there are obvious exceptions if the case and/or the accused are extremely high profile (the recent accusations against Bill Cosby come to find), very few media outlets would ever report even the most basic personal info (such as a name) without a formal charge having been laid.

It's silly to try to compare unsubstantiated allegations made on a review/discussion board to the media reporting on police investigations.

That said, many sex workers feel isolated from the legal system (for obvious reasons) and are not comfortable dealing with the police. Bad client lists give them an opportunity to share knowledge and protect themselves. Although there is always a chance of inaccurate or even malicious information being provided on such lists, keeping access restricted to the core group of people that need it seems to be a reasonable trade-off. In a worst case scenario, a falsely accused John might find it more difficult to book a date. While unfair, it's hardly the end of the world. The consequences of having your personal information posted in a public forum, however, could be far more serious.

As for Paige's asinine comment that "some sex workers can't be bothered with passwords", my only response would be "too fucking bad". We have passwords for our bank cards, our voice mail, our e-mail, E-bay, tax software, etc., ad naseum. If you are so fucking lazy that you "can't be bothered" to have a password to access information that can protect well, quite frankly, you're probably too fucking lazy (or stupid) to find and read the information in the first place.

Allowing personal information in public forums, except in the most extreme circumstances, is an outrageously bad idea. Think about some of the people on these boards - the nuts and whack jobs and Cardinal Fang - do you really think that they should have access to private information based on a simple accusation? Is that wise or safe for anyone?