Speculations on 911

cogterb

New member
Aug 1, 2003
60
0
0
I kind of buried this in another thread and felt it deserved it's own thread instead.

(Comments about tin foil hats by over-zealous moderators are welcome)

I propose that 9/11 was the useful crisis that the Project for a New American Century was waiting for.
Maybe their friends in the CIA and other foreign secret service organizations had some role in staging the attacks.

following excerpt from
"Rebuilding America's Defenses -- Strategy, Forces, and Resources for a New Century,"
Project for the New American Century, September 2000

"To preserve American military
preeminence in the coming decades, the
Department of Defense must move more
aggressively to experiment with new
technologies and operational concepts, and
seek to exploit the emerging revolution in
military affairs. Information technologies,
in particular, are becoming more prevalent
and significant components of modern
military systems. These information tech-nologies
are having the same kind of trans-forming
effects on military affairs as they
are having in the larger world. The effects
of this military transformation will have
profound implications for how wars are
fought, what kinds of weapons will
dominate the battlefield and, inevitably,
which nations enjoy military preeminence."

"the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor."

http://www.newamericancentury.org/RebuildingAmericasDefenses.pdf

Some of the pilots trained at a flight school in Venice, Florida next to Jackson Stephens building. Stephens was earlier implicated in the BCCI scandal and secret National Security Agency operations.

Members of the Bin Laden family were meeting with George Bush senior at a Carlisle Group meeting on September 11 2001 in Washington and where later FLOWN out on private jets even when all commercial air traffic was grounded.

It is well known that Osama Bin Laden was aided by the CIA in the late 1980's in building and supporting the the Afghani "freedom fighters" against the Russians. Some of those freedom fighters went on to become the Taliban and Al Quaeda.

Also note the Pakistan ISI (secret service) connection below:

Excerpt from
Pakistani Role in Terrorism Against the U.S.A
by Narayanan Komerath

General Mehmood Ahmed, ISI Chief, was visiting the State Department when the attack on the Pentagon occurred – and he had practically a direct view of the event. From "ISI Chief Lt-Gen. Mahmoud's week-long presence in Washington has triggered speculation about the agenda of his mysterious meetings at the Pentagon and National Security Council. .. most important meeting was with Marc Grossman, U.S. Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs. One can safely guess that the discussions must have centred around Afghanistan . . . and Osama bin Laden."A final hint of ISI involvement in the 9/11 attack comes in the assassination of Northern Alliance leader Ahmed Shah Masood on September 9 using a suicide bomb in a TV camera, and hints on bin Laden’s whereabouts. Bin Laden was reported to be in Pakistan for “medical treatment” around that time.
 
so here's my dilemma

Osama Bin Laden, assuming he wanted to destroy the USA.
Why then would he hand them their Useful Crisis on a silver platter?

He's a smart guy, he would have known about PNAC and its objectives of global military superiority.
 
Folks
spend more energy on monday morning quaterbacking.

One can find a proof for every theory.

Toss in a 50% reduction on home forces in the previous 8 years.

Toss in a previous administration governing by taking a poll to see what he should do.

Toss in an untried leader and to everones suprise he got up firing.


Kick back and enjoy the superbowl. Atleast the entire game can be seen by all.
 
papasmerf said:

Toss in an untried leader and to everones suprise he got up firing.


You are assuming he makes his own decisions.
That's the beautiful illusion. Removing Bush won't solve this problem. It goes deeper.
 
papasmerf said:
reduction on home forces in the previous 8 years.


Armed forces should be there to protect our country against foreign invasion - not to protect and extend our global domination.

That would not be democratic in a world sense. It would be facism.
 
cogterb said:
so here's my dilemma

Osama Bin Laden, assuming he wanted to destroy the USA.
Why then would he hand them their Useful Crisis on a silver platter?

He's a smart guy, he would have known about PNAC and its objectives of global military superiority.

simple, he wanted a) to create a symbol for terrorists to look to as proof that they can bring down America's power over the world, and b) to produce fear mongering like the patriot act which will result in American's taking away their own freedom.

I don't believe 9/11 conspiracy theories because I believe the loss of life was unacceptable even for such a plot. the twin towers was one of the two most powerful images to target (the white house being the best) but on a sunday (christian gods day) with maybe a few hundred people inside the impact is equal and with less innocent victims, I can't see the government killing that many unnecessary innocent victims.
 
cogterb said:
You are assuming he makes his own decisions.
That's the beautiful illusion. Removing Bush won't solve this problem. It goes deeper.


Got news for ya, bro

I support Bush and a strong homeland security.
 
the reason Oklahoma didn't work was that it was a white American terrorist, make him a foreign Muslim and it would have been 9/11.
 
papasmerf said:
One can find a proof for every theory.

Except, it seems, that WMD theory that's been tossed around for the last year and a half.

Toss in a previous administration governing by taking a poll to see what he should do.

This shows how ridiculous your arguments are. Purely desperate to complain about Clinton.....probably because you can't think of a lie-to-get-us-into-war reason. They're elected to serve the people.....so they should damn well know what the people want who elected them. If you think Bush doesn't do idiotic, moronic, imbecilic things only to "play to his base", then you're more ignorant than even i give you credit for.

Toss in an untried leader and to everones suprise he got up firing.

Yeah, and his aim shows just how untried he is.
 
gramage said:
I can't see the government killing that many unnecessary innocent victims.

Well, at last count, 522 innocent victims don't seem to be too many for 'em.

For the record however, i don't personally subscribe to the 9/11 theories. Though i will say that Bush is pathetic for allowing himself to be considered a hero when he did nothing to prevent it, while allowing the yahoos to blame Clinton for having done just as little.
 
gramage said:
on a sunday with maybe a few hundred people inside the impact is equal and with less innocent victims, I can't see the government killing that many unnecessary innocent victims.



Then it wouldn't be a "Useful Crisis" would it?
 
Interesting names on PNAC

Out of interest look at the names who signed
"Project for a New American Century"
in 1997

some are very familiar

This is not a democratic organization. It is a private group of people bent on extending American global power.

If that's not a conspiracy, what the hell is?

Elliott Abrams Gary Bauer William J. Bennett Jeb Bush

Dick Cheney Eliot A. Cohen Midge Decter Paula Dobriansky Steve Forbes

Aaron Friedberg Francis Fukuyama Frank Gaffney Fred C. Ikle

Donald Kagan Zalmay Khalilzad I. Lewis Libby Norman Podhoretz

Dan Quayle Peter W. Rodman Stephen P. Rosen Henry S. Rowen

Donald Rumsfeld Vin Weber George Weigel Paul Wolfowitz
 
cogterb said:
Armed forces should be there to protect our country against foreign invasion - not to protect and extend our global domination.

That would not be democratic in a world sense. It would be facism.

This from a country with money that has another countries fat old woman on it?

The US has no need of a military for home defense, our two land neighbors are so incompetent and weak they couldn't make it 50 miles before their logistical train failed. A military is used to protect a countries interests. In the US case those interests are far flung. The difference between our activities and those of Old Europe is that we fight wars to give people their freedom and Old Europe fought wars to take it away. Hence the old broad on your currency.

OTB
 
How about it mods
This is just another BUSH Bashing anti-American thread.

Do we really nee another one?????
 
onthebottom said:
we fight wars to give people their freedom
OTB


Do you really believe that crap about giving people their freedom?
No outside nation gave the valiant USA their freedom in 1776.
They fought hard against the oppressors and won.
Maybe God helped give them their freedom.
Has the USA elevated itself to the status of God now?
(A lot of them sure behave that way).
 
cogterb said:
Do you really believe that crap about giving people their freedom?
No outside nation gave the valiant USA their freedom in 1776.
They fought hard against the oppressors and won.
Maybe God helped give them their freedom.
Has the USA elevated itself to the status of God now?
(A lot of them sure behave that way).
If Judgement is mine, sayith the Lord.

Then you are who you fault.
 
Well

cogterb said:
Do you really believe that crap about giving people their freedom?.

Yes, ask Europe.

cogterb said:

No outside nation gave the valiant USA their freedom in 1776.

The French helped, more to spite the British than to help us I think but it would be in bad form not to give them credit for it.


cogterb said:
...
Has the USA elevated itself to the status of God now?
(A lot of them sure behave that way).

Well, we did return the favor a couple of times last century. So what you are saying is that the British should have been able to protect their empire all on their own in the 30's and 40's. Singapore fell almost immediately, the British were moon walking the wrong way in Northern Africa and got the arses kicked off the continent in an embarrassing amount of time. You know you're pathetic when your major triumphs are a retreat and the air battle OVER your capital city.

Maybe we should have stayed home and let them fight harder - but then you'd have a funny looking guy with a stash on your money.

OTB