Sukdeep said:The highest marginal rate of 46% kicks in at about $107K (if memory serves), which is a lot better than the 53% at $59K a few years ago.
Sure, you're hourly rate will diminish as you escalate up the pay scale. But, you are still adding to your overall wealth. At least most (54%) of what you earn stays with you.
High tax rates do result in uneconomical decision-making. As intimated in this thread, there may be a "psychological" barrier at $107K. At $107K, people may simply say, "I've worked all than I want to work, because working any harder is not worth it".
This, along with the "underground economy" are the best reasons for reducing tax rates. As a capitalist society, we should value ambition and hard work.
onthebottom said:Line of math and thinking drove a much-maligned economic concept called the lauffer curve. Arthur Lauffer supposed that (from the Governments perspective) that if tax rates were 0% the government would collect 0 AND if the tax rate were 100% the government would also collect 0 because no one would bother work.
If you followed the above you must realize that at some point, as you raise tax RATES tax income falls because taxes are a disincentive to work (which generates wealth). The curve is where the graph (think of this as tax rates on the X axis and tax revenue on the Y axis) turns back to the left.
Some anecdotal evidence (that will really piss off the anit-USers on this board) would be to look at the US. The US has the highest per capita income (wealth creation) of large countries and the lowest marginal tax rates. So the lesson is (for those of you going to the church of Regannomics - to which I belong) that the lower the taxes the richer the economy.
tboy said:2) all expenses paid vacation: NOT taxable as of yet (aka 2 weeks in bahama's)
4) Gift Certificates: Home Depot or ?? Gift Cards: company gets a tax break for these gifts and they are tax free to you
Lets say he made $64,368 (taxable income) this year (2003), he would pay $12,230 fed tax. This is approximately 19%. (Note , this does not include provincial tax, etc).tboy said:....If say JJ works so much ot that it puts him into the next bracket, he will be taxed on his entire pay, at the higher rate.
Fortunato said:Well, Mr. OTB, you seem to be confusing concepts again.
First, the way you throw around the term "rates"... Laffer (not Lauffer) bases his premise on overall tax rates (tax "totals" as a proportion of income, as it were); however, the question involved relates to "marginal" tax rates. In progressive tax regimes (like Canada and the US), it is a falacy to assume that making more will EVER make you worse off (the uninitiated "tax bracket" argument), because the increased rates are only for the increased amount you earn. To use Laffer's hypothesis to suggest that our poor friend Mr. Jam is not better off by taking the additional work (even if he is better off only at a decreasing rate) is irresponsible.
Fortunato said:
Second, I disagree with your assertion that taxation is the primary reason for economic success. If that were the case, taxation arbitrage would have destroyed even your majestic US economy, for preferable environments in many other areas. Likewise, we would expect greater continuous success from other economies focusing on low taxes (Ireland, Russia, etc.). And to suggest "causation" from such a simple model is as logically valid as saying "US has low marginal tax rates", and "gravity works"... therefore "low tax rates creates gravity for all Americans".
Fortunato said:
Don't get me wrong - I loathe taxes myself, and encourage both tax and spending cuts... but that is because I don't believe that governments spend money well (I don't believe the propaganda that tax cuts for the rich, or deficit spending "creates wealth")... and I am far from being anything you could refer to as "liberal". However, I cannot help but laugh at "Reaganomics" (as you quote) simply because it seems entirely based on illogical conclusions.
Well, that and I find most true disciples of Reaganomics are just plain wierd.
Best regards,
F.
Here is one time I will agree with OTB. There is a crucial taxation balance point after which it either does not pay to work (be a slave) or it pays to cheat and the economy goes underground. In both of these cases the government looses tax money. However we could debate the merit of; tax cuts only or mostly for the rich as opposed to mostly for the working class and deficit spending. But those are entirely different issues.onthebottom said:... if tax rates were 0% the government would collect 0 AND if the tax rate were 100% the government would also collect 0 because no one would bother work.
Fortunato said:To use Laffer's hypothesis to suggest that our poor friend Mr. Jam is not better off by taking the additional work (even if he is better off only at a decreasing rate) is irresponsible.
Don't get me wrong - I loathe taxes myself, and encourage both tax and spending cuts... but that is because I don't believe that governments spend money well (I don't believe the propaganda that tax cuts for the rich, or deficit spending "creates wealth")... and I am far from being anything you could refer to as "liberal". However, I cannot help but laugh at "Reaganomics" (as you quote) simply because it seems entirely based on illogical conclusions.
jimjam said:I work alot of OT with my job. I`m paid by the hour. Just want to where the fine line is. After how many hours do I stop getting paid and therest goes to Ottawa.
onthebottom said:While I undersand your point I don't know that it changes the argument. If the more I make the less I take home as a percentage continues, people will be less incented to work, as with our case study that started this thread. That was really the point, everyone has a threashold at which they'd rather sit home and watch TV than work.
OTB
drlove said:Make no mistake about it - MORE is what it's all about - it's the American Dream. Do you want more money or less?? It's up to you. Point being, stop wasting your time thinking about losing money. Better that you devote all your time and energy into figuring out how to get more money in YOUR pocket. You'd be surprised at the end result.
Pay raises are fine, usually one does not have to work more, one just gets paid more. For OT one has to work more hours. For many the extra hours (a jump just over the line in the tax bracket) are not worth the little extra in pay. That is the point. Hey anyone can get a second job at night making minimum wage, why don't you all do it? You would surely bring home more money!spartan5782 said:Using the logic being kicked around here in regards to overtime, the same I guess can be said in relation to pay raises?
tompeepin said:Pay raises are fine, usually one does not have to work more, one just get paid more. For OT one has to work more hours. For many the extra hours (a jump just over the line in the tax bracket) are not worth the little extra in pay. That is the point. Hey anyone can get a second job at night making minimum wage, why don't you all do it? You would surely bring home more money!
onthebottom said:While I undersand your point I don't know that it changes the argument. If the more I make the less I take home as a percentage continues, people will be less incented to work, as with our case study that started this thread. That was really the point, everyone has a threashold at which they'd rather sit home and watch TV than work.
onthebottom said:I Don't know that I said it was the "Primary reason", I just said that if you look to PEER economies (the US doesn't really have a peer economy but the other G8 are as close as you can get) you will find that Americans make more money and are taxed less. You would also find our unemployment the lowest, I wonder if that's a function of lower taxes (may as well work if I can keep more of it) or more market based labour market (lower payments for sitting on your ass). There are no simple cause and effects in macro econmics, but trends can be diserned, and those trends favor open labor markets and lower taxes.
OTB
tompeepin said:Pay raises are fine, usually one does not have to work more, one just gets paid more. For OT one has to work more hours. For many the extra hours (a jump just over the line in the tax bracket) are not worth the little extra in pay. That is the point. Hey anyone can get a second job at night making minimum wage, why don't you all do it? You would surely bring home more money!