Joey Jeremiah said:
What are your thoughts on them? Are you part of one? I am just curious, since I know absolutely jack about them...
Do they serve a useful purpose in protecting employees? Do they discourage innovation and stifle the top performers?
Timely question for me since our Union Agreement expires this April and we are about to begin negotiations (I'm on the Management side of things).
I honestly prefer working with a Union when dealing with straight labor (truck drivers and warehouse workers). There's not much creativity there, so having set rules and regulations, job classifications, wages and wage increases for the next 4 years makes it a damn site easier for me. If there's a problem, I deal with the Steward, one voice, rather than a line up of individuals.
For the members, their security is knowing that they are interchangable within a classification, so layoffs and recalls are seniority based...meaning the new young kid will get cut before the 20 year vet. They don't have to look over their shoulder wondering if they are going to be replaced by youth, as long as they can perform the job.
Other than layoffs or job eliminations (possibly shift preference and overtime), not much else Seniority will protect. A violation of the Agreement can still lead to discipline and termination, and the member can file a grievance, but if it's in the contract, and due process has be adhered to, then he won't have a case. It does however prevent Management from "creating" an infraction and chosing to terminate without just cause.
Like anything else, there's pros and cons. The strength of the Union and language of the Agreement determines a good working relationship.
Now, if you are dealing with job descriptions that's more subjective and creative, such as sales, R&D, marketing, management...all where performance should lead to higher compensation, then I'd shy away from leveling the comp because it would lead to less initiative and drive. Just my opinion...hopes this helps.