Will The CanCons Go For Recurring Dynasties?
Who should replace Pierre Poilievre?
Lawrence MartinPublic affairs columnist
Special to The Globe and Mail
Published 6 hours ago
For Subscribers
Open this photo in gallery:

Pierre Poilievre, Conservative Party leader and MP for Battle River-Crowfoot, speaks at The Royal Canadian Legion in Wainwright, Alta., on Nov. 11.Megan Albu/The Globe and Mail
180 Comments
Share
Save for later
Give this article
Listen to this article
Learn more about audio
05:11
1x
How much losing can one man take?
Pierre Poilievre lost the last election, and in it, he lost his riding. He subsequently lost several members of his caucus, thereby helping the Liberals attain a majority.
The Conservative Leader, who lost some of his key policies to the poaching Liberals, has decidedly lost the support of the people. His rating as preferred prime minister in the
latest Nanos poll is a ghastly 20 per cent compared to Mark Carney’s 56.
This week came news of yet more losses, with many of Mr. Poilievre’s
staff members exiting.
What else is there to lose? Quite likely a long-held Conservative seat in Brantford in by-elections coming on Dec. 7.
If the party is to drop Mr. Poilievre – a caucus vote could lead to it happening – the best opportunity is when he is at rock bottom. Which is in the current time frame.
Two senior Poilievre staffers decamp to BC Conservatives
In the wings are some potentially good leaders who, if they decide to run, could resurrect Conservative hopes.
Many in the party would prefer a leader with Stephen Harper’s substantive strengths. One who fits that bill and is less callous is James Moore. The British Columbian is wickedly smart, bilingual, deeply experienced. He is a builder not a blamer. He would have difficulty appealing to convoy Conservatives, but so would other leadership aspirants.
Mr. Moore, 50,
posted a photo of himself with Mr. Harper at last weekend’s Grey Cup game in Calgary. They both were grinning. “Having fun watching football & talking politics at the Grey Cup,” the caption said. Peter MacKay was in the photo smiling too. There was no Mr. Poilievre.
If the party wants to reach outside like the Liberals did with Mark Carney and bring in a newcomer, there’s someone who fits that bill also. A banker even.
More stories below advertisement
00:02 / 00:06
Mark Mulroney has extensive experience in investment banking and capital markets and worked, like Mr. Carney, at Goldman Sachs. He is now Global Vice-Chair of CIBC.
Mr. Mulroney has much of his father’s bilingual charm.
He’s never run for political office. But Mr. Carney has made that limitation sound like an asset. There’s no baggage.
Mr. Mulroney’s sister Caroline served until recently in Doug Ford’s cabinet in Ontario, but she doesn’t appear to be interested in going federal.
If the party wants to turn over the reins to a woman, however, they have a firebrand communicator in deputy leader Melissa Lantsman. The Toronto MP speaks several languages, is sharp as a knife in a debate and can take her party’s appeal beyond traditional constituencies. Her difficulty would be her very close association with Mr. Poilievre.
Andrew Coyne: The real immigration ‘fib’? Far fewer migrants are entering Canada than official figures say
For an experience-loaded candidate with organizational muscle there’s Jason Kenney, who served in major cabinet jobs under Mr. Harper and also as Premier of Alberta. He’s been all over TV screens recently. His understanding of key files such as immigration, multiculturalism, energy and U.S. relations is appreciable. His challenge would be overcoming the ill will he unleashed as head of Alberta’s United Conservative Party, which forced him out via a leadership review vote.
Percolating on the East Coast for the party is Tim Houston, a feisty retail politician who won a second mandate as Nova Scotia Premier in 2024.
Several ambitious caucus members like Adam Chambers and Michelle Rempel Garner are handicapped by having little or no French. That applies equally to Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who
amusingly stumbled over a few words in French in Montreal this week.
Despite his many millstones, Mr. Poilievre maintains much support from the harder right segment of the party. Since that faction’s rise under the Reform banner and establishment as the movement’s dominant force in 1993, conservatives have been in power only nine of the last 33 years (36 years by the next election slated for 2029).
To improve on that dismal record, the party needs a new leader who can move it closer to the mainstream. Most of the aforementioned potential candidates could do that. But the leadership isn’t available and might not be before the election unless the party moves quickly.
Mr. Carney’s extraordinarily high support numbers will inevitably fall. The Conservatives are likely to pick up some of that support and it will encourage Mr. Poilievre to soldier on.
Soldier on and drag the party down with him, unless something strange happens like what occurred with Justin Trudeau. He was decapitated by the resignation of his deputy leader Chrystia Freeland, a move that likely saved the party from a rout.
But the CPC can’t expect Ms. Lantsman to do a drastic deed like that. It’s the kind of luck that only the Liberals get.